The film never takes the time to consider how little thought Khan would’ve given to killing Pike, a disabled person. Khan likely believes that all disabled people deserve to die for the good of humanity. Hell, he probably had an extermination program against disabled people during his heyday. By ignoring Khan’s eugenicist ableism, the film loses a good deal of the moral complexity found in Star Trek.

We never see Admiral Marcus weigh the options of aligning with a genocidal murderer in the name of Federation security. If Khan advised him to implement a eugenics policy to save the Federation, would Marcus do it? Who would Marcus kill to protect the many? Would he go for Pike, one of his own officers?

We also never see Kirk truly consider the ethical implications of teaming up with Khan for the infiltration of Marcus’ starship. Is Kirk just as bad as Marcus now? By partnering with a man who would want Pike exterminated, does Kirk betray his memory? Is stopping Marcus worth the risk of Khan escaping and conquering Earth again?

But none of these kind of questions get asked in the film because the J.J. Abrams version of Star Trek is more interested in gunfights and girls in their underwear than the hard questions that need to be debated to build a better future for life on this planet and far beyond.
Star Trek Into Darkness: Able-Bodied Angst and Abrams’ Anti-Intellectualism
  1. seanchaidh101 reblogged this from spacecrip
  2. wasiantori reblogged this from vulcanwulcan
  3. willgrahamspsychiatrist reblogged this from dammit-jim-im-a-fangirl
  4. teddyrlupin reblogged this from favouritegirlband
  5. kadrimhaesinddare reblogged this from dammit-jim-im-a-fangirl
  6. dammit-jim-im-a-fangirl reblogged this from assemblinlikeanavenger
  7. michaeljfaux reblogged this from ussawesome
  8. vulcanwulcan reblogged this from favouritegirlband
  9. captaindog reblogged this from weird-bird-headingnorth
  10. blueminuet reblogged this from unfilteredinferno
  11. whoknewwebelieved reblogged this from favouritegirlband
  12. unfilteredinferno reblogged this from muckkles
  13. assemblinlikeanavenger reblogged this from muckkles
  14. muckkles reblogged this from shatterdomerockstars
  15. madame-squiggly reblogged this from shatterdomerockstars
  16. shatterdomerockstars reblogged this from favouritegirlband
  17. favouritegirlband reblogged this from ussawesome
  18. tyken-grayne-thost reblogged this from spacecrip
  19. lexdysic reblogged this from shards-of-divinity
  20. albion-echo reblogged this from flarechaser
  21. heavens2betsy reblogged this from treksfromlastnight
  22. jaegersbutt reblogged this from teaandcrumpets
  23. selume-proferre reblogged this from andromedanandroid
  24. teaandcrumpets reblogged this from andromedanandroid
  25. nerdylittleshit reblogged this from treksfromlastnight
  26. unavailingterran reblogged this from ilinalta
  27. gotrekyourself reblogged this from snarkydiscolizard
The Tumblr home-away-from-home of Space Crip.

view archive

Ask me anything